I keep on wanting to leave behind my 3-part series on Australia’s xenophobia (one, two, three), but reality just won’t let me.
What I hadn’t mentioned in my original posts was the recent addition of an Indian element to the equation because — believe it or not — I didn’t want this to turn into a hate-fest of Australia, but more a measured (albeit brutal) assessment of a country I once used to call home. However, in a recent article in The Age, we learn that:
[Indian] groups have been gathering at St Albans and Thomastown railway stations after a spate of assaults on Indians in the area, the latest on Kamal Jit, 23, who was bashed unconscious while walking home from the St Albans railway station on the weekend.
There has been a beating on a train, assaults, stabbings. And then the Indians retaliated:
[A police spokeswoman] refused to confirm whether two men who stabbed a 20-year-old man in St Albans yesterday were Indians lashing out after being racially abused by the victim. [although, the article tells me a bit further on, police "want to speak to [two men] over the attack … aged between 23 and 29 years old and dark-skinned.” — ed.]
No one has yet been charged over the incident.
The victim allegedly said: “You are black. You don’t belong here. Go away from our country”.
(Now, remember, according to Australian migrant author Alice Pung, this is not racism with any “long term adverse effect[s]“, but merely “casual name-calling”. But I digress.)
You know what. I can sympathise with the Indian students. If there’s anything that pushes my buttons, it’s being called names by the truly ignorant. The problem is, the nanosecond you physically retaliate, you give the ignorant exactly the kind of positive affirmation they’re looking for. You prove that you can be as barbaric as them, and give them physical badges of honour that they can then use to sway other ignorant gits to their side. (What’s that you say? No, I’m not talking about US foreign policy, although there is a parallel here, now that you mention it. Let’s just stick to Indian students in Melbourne for the time being, okay?)
I know that the Indians think they’re sticking up for themselves. After all, by walking away, they’re just going to be called cowards, and that’s a tough one to swallow. But beating up some white isn’t going to solve the situation either, is it?
My solution? Leave. It’s what I did. The reality is this. There are enough ignorant gits around for you not to make a blind bit of difference. Plus, any negative publicity about any migrant anywhere is going to get headline focus. There’s another reason I say ‘leave’:
One man, who did not want his name published, said [the students] took the action “in self-defence” after police failed to respond to their call for protection in the wake of attacks on fellow Indian students … “The police don’t care. In this suburb everyone is a migrant,” he said.
His claims were verified by another person who witnessed the attacks but did not want his name published.
and
In other incidents on the same night, a group of Indians were abused by a group of males and one Indian was punched but when the police arrived, “they did not do anything”, The Age was told.
Here’s a truism. The police are not there for your protection. They are there to protect the system. In communism, they were/are there to protect the State apparatus. In capitalism, they’re there to protect the ruling financial class. And, as Cronulla, Melbourne, and dozens of Aboriginal communities in Queensland have proven, in Australia they’re there to protect the whites. What are you, coloured student, going to do about it? You can’t win. Just leave.
But isn’t this playing right into the hands of those xenophobic bastards, you ask? Yes and no. Yes, in the short-term. Victory for Real Australians™ everywhere! But in the long term?
What if every coloured family who could afford to send their beloved child overseas for an education refused to send them to Australia? Who do you think make up the bulk of Australia’s foreign students? Whites or coloureds? And where do you think the majority of university funding comes from? Local or foreign student fees? While it may not seem obvious on the surface, it’s actually the coloured parents that hold the direction of Australian public policy in their hands, thanks to the strangling of Australian federal funds to higher institutions for more than a decade now. The problem is, those coloured parents are all in such different countries, with different perspectives and motivations, that it’s impossible to mould them into one effective public action group, if you will. But news will out. I find the locals here in Malaysia, for example, to be gratifyingly well-informed on the policies of a frightening array of countries.
And so I say to you again. You can’t change them. And do you want your child taunted or injured? If you’re there, leave. At least you’ll still have your dignity, instead of sinking to the level of people you know you shouldn’t have anything to do with.
POSTSCRIPT: For contrast, look at the furore between (white Australian) Tracy Grimshaw and (white British) celebrity chef, Gordon Ramsey. Three comments on three days and Grimshaw is already talking about it being “not a joke to me, or to anyone who cares about me”, “I wonder how many people would laugh if they were described as an ‘old, ugly pig’”, and how horrible it was when her mother found out about it.
Of course, Grimshaw has it right. There is no, no, NO excuse for the kind of inane comments Ramsey came out with. But, you know what? If it had been me in that situation, I wouldn’t have given it a second thought beyond an opportunity for some perhaps delicious verbal sparring, just because I’ve had decades more than three days to get used to it.